Side dish

Jalapeño dill potato salad

Jalapeno dill potato salad | Homesick Texan

Last weekend I attended my first outdoor gathering of the season, and I brought one of my usual potluck standbys, my pinto bean and hominy salad. The cool combination of beans and hominy along with a medley of peppers, tomatoes, and aromatics reminiscent of pico de gallo not only travels well but also is tangy and flavorful enough to be a good foil to smoked and grilled meats. It’s always a hit.

That said, I’m often on the hunt for new dishes to bring to barbecues. Recently, Paula Forbes’ new collection of recipes called The Austin Cookbook was delivered to my mailbox, and while I had provided an endorsement for the book pre-publication, it was satisfying to hold the finished work in my hands, especially since my friend Robert Strickland shot the engaging photographs. It’s a bright and lively book.

Like many Texans, I lived in Austin at one point in my life and in fact it was the last place I called home before moving to New York City. Sure, in the passing years the city has certainly grown and changed quite a bit. But whenever I visit, at its core I can still sense that quirky, laid-back town I fell in love with so many years ago.

Paula, a native of Wisconsin, moved to Austin in 2006 and also fell in love with the city after she arrived. She was the founding editor of Eater Austin, and for her book she taps into her deep knowledge of Austin’s restaurants and chefs. As such, the recipes traverse both traditional Austin fare such as migas and smoked brisket, and new Austin favorites such as beet fries and banh mi tacos. This book is her way of celebrating the place that she adores.

Jalapeno dill potato salad | Homesick Texan

There are many dishes that I’m curious to make such as Lucy’s fried chicken and Parkside’s macaroni and cheese. I’m also eager to smoke a turkey breast as per La Barbecue, but until I have a yard, I’ll be putting off that project for a while (though I have been tempted to see how it would turn out in my stovetop smoker). But as we move towards summer and the season of backyard get-togethers, I’m all about the side dishes and there’s an assortment of those in the book, too.

One cold salad that caught my eye was Kerlin BBQ’s jalapeño dill potato salad. Most potato salads served at Texas barbecue joints are made with a mustard base, though this one bucks tradition and uses mayonnaise mixed with sour cream for its tang. There’s a healthy dose of pickled jalapeños involved along with handfuls of chopped fresh dill and scallions, too. So, while a bit unconventional, the combination of ingredients sounded bright and fresh. I decided to give it a try.

After gathering my ingredients, putting the salad together took little effort, and the only addition I made was tossing the potatoes with jalapeño pickle juice for an extra kick. As I stirred everything together in a big bowl, I kept sneaking bites as it was so good. As a matter of fact, Paula had warned about this temptation in her headnote. So, while I enjoyed it warm, I followed her advice to chill it for a spell. And after a few hours the pungency of the dill, scallions, sour cream, and pickled peppers still gave the salad quite a pop.

Jalapeno dill potato salad | Homesick Texan

In the upcoming weeks, I have a few more parties on the horizon and I’m thrilled to share something new. This salad will make a fine addition to any side-dish spread. While I’d always been a staunch fan of mustard in my potato salad, the dill and pickled jalapeños offer plenty of brightness to offset the richness of smoked meats. Indeed, this salad is familiar yet new—much like the city of Austin itself.

Jalapeno dill potato salad | Homesick Texan
4.67 from 3 votes

Jalapeño dill potato salad

Servings 10
Author Adapted very slightly by Lisa Fain from Paula Forbes' The Austin Cookbook


  • 5 pounds red potatoes, skin on
  • 1 tablespoon kosher salt
  • 2 tablespoons jalapeño juice
  • 2 bunches scallions, green part only, thinly sliced
  • 1 cup chopped fresh dill
  • 1 cup chopped pickled jalapeños
  • 1 cup sour cream
  • 1 cup mayonnaise
  • 1/2 teaspoon black pepper


  1. Place the potatoes in a large pot, cover with cold water and add the salt. Bring to a boil then continue to cook for 20 minutes or until fork tender. Drain the potatoes, and when cool enough to handle, cut into ¼-inch cubes.

  2. Place the cut potatoes into a large bowl. Toss the potatoes with the jalapeño pickle juice, then gently stir in the scallions, dill, jalapeños, sour cream, mayonnaise, and black pepper until well combined. Taste and adjust seasonings, adding more salt if needed.

  3. Cover and refrigerate for at least 1 hour, though preferably overnight, before serving.

  1. I wonder if you’re familiar with the Austrian/German twist of dousing the HOT cut-up potatoes with well-seasoned broth/bouillon before dressing the salad. It adds lots of flavor.

    I love the notion of pickled jalapenos in potato salad and ANY dressing but mustard (I’m not fond of mustard). I generally use an oil/vinegar one, but am eager to try this one (most likely substituting Greek yoghurt).

    • Lisa Fain

      Greta–I’m not familiar with dousing the potatoes in broth, but that sounds like a fantastic way to add flavor. And yogurt would be equally delicious in this, too! Enjoy!

      • That’s how I like it! Bring to boil a mix of vinegar, pepper, sugar and broth, then add cubed onion (preferably red) and pour over still warm sliced boiled potatoes. Add some neutral oil and hot mustard and finish with fresh chives to taste

  2. I’m not a big fan of mayo and this sounds like WAY more than I would like (though it sounds wonderful otherwise, since I love jalapenos and dill). What do you think about substituting 1/2 of the mayo for mustard? Too weird?
    Ronda in Austin

    • Lisa Fain

      Ronda–That might work though it would be very tangy! You could also just cut the mayo in half, taste, and see if it’s creamy enough as is.

  3. I am going to try this this weekend. I was thinkin go substituting my candied jalapeno for the pickled jalapeno. A little sweeter but that’s ok for me. Just not a big pickled jalapeno fan. I usually use candied dills in my potato salad.

    • Lisa Fain

      J Mark–That’s an excellent idea! I love candied jalapeños in potato salad.

  4. I’m thinking I’m going to add a couple hard boiled eggs, chopped, when I make this. Eggs and jalepenos go together well! Thanks for this recipe, Lisa.

    • Lisa Fain

      JoyceK–They do go very well together. That sounds like a terrific addition!

  5. Love this idea. Dill is my all time favorite herb and who doesn’t like jalepeno?

    • Lisa Fain

      Rocky Mountain Woman–Indeed, all the flavors play so well together!

  6. I grew up with the mustard/mayo/sweet pickle style potato salad popular in both the midwest and south, but as a new bride in northern Palm Beach County, FL, encountered a similar salad to this one using the 50/50 mix of sour cream and mayo plus dill pickles and/or fresh dill. It sometimes included chopped egg and/or celery–we thought it was a NY recipe as neighbors who served it were snowbirds from NYC. It was fairly widespread in the area, however, and we definitely considered it a Yankee recipe. I liked it a lot, but DH didn’t care for it, so it gradually dropped from my rotation. Using jalapenos instead of dill pickles, however, would perk up any mustardless version, and I can’t wait to try it! I’ve been known to use some Rope Burn pepper relish or chopped Wickles to perk up my sweet pickle version of potato salad. Thanks

    • Lisa Fain

      Janet–The jalapeños definitely perk it up. I hope you enjoy!

  7. I don’t like potato salad. However, my husband and teenage son love it. So, I made a batch of this for Memorial Day weekend.

    The result? I could not stop eating it. It is soooo good. I’m swearing off all other potato salad recipes. The menfolk loved it too. Thanks!

  8. Ooooh, i can’t wait to make this for a BBQ tomorrow! I think I’ll steal one of the suggestions above and douse the hot potatoes with dill pickle juice. I think that’ll be sooooooo tasty. Will report back.

  9. Michele

    This is soooo good! Loved it. Might add celery next time just because I’m a crunch fiend. Don’t understand why I can’t just chop the potato THEN boil? It was all gummy and hard to deal with when trying to cut them cooked. Will try it reversed next time.

    • Lisa Fain

      Michele–Glad you enjoyed it! And cutting the potatoes first works absolutely works well, too!

  10. Lisa I love this and have been making for years now.Thank you! I want to make in a few day’s and nobody has fresh dill,would dried work?I was thing maybe 4 TB or so what do you think?

    • Lisa Fain

      David–It would be fine with dried dill. And that amount sounds about right, though you could always start with less, taste, and then add more if needed.

      • Thank you.I’m so glad as i’m craving it.I’m sure the fresh would be better.You made me very happy!

  11. Whitney

    Yum! We’re Texans living in Hartford, CT and I made this yesterday for the first time to go with a brisket my husband smoked and my great grandmaw’s banana pudding recipe. I love how the picked jalapeños add a little kick and tang and especially love the sour cream and dill with it. I’m currently eating a leftover bowl in my 80 degree house—I miss Texas air conditioning haha

    • Lisa Fain

      Whitney–What a fine Texas-style feast, and I’m so glad y’all enjoyed the potato salad. Hope it helps you stay cool!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating