Side dish

Squash casserole, Dallas cafeteria style

Squash casserole, Dallas cafeteria style | Homesick Texan

The past couple of years have not been kind to restaurants and we’ve lost quite a few. One that has been lamented is Highland Park Cafeteria, a Dallas comfort-food mainstay that served people from all walks of life for over 95 years before it closed its doors last year.

Growing up in Houston, my family frequented Luby’s, so Highland Park Cafeteria wasn’t a place I visited often. In fact, the only memory I have of going there was during college.

A friend and I were visiting her grandmother who lived close by, and she took us there for dinner, as it was her favorite place to eat. What we ate that evening has been forgotten. But I would be surprised if the cafeteria’s beloved squash casserole was not part of our meal

Now, there are many ways to make a squash casserole, which is always a fine way to use up the season’s yellow crookneck squash and/or zucchini bounty. For instance, I enjoy making it into a Tex-Mex style dish with tortilla chips, Ro-tel tomatoes, and lots of cheese. Though it’s also enjoyable baked with saltines, eggs, and peppers, or simply sautéed with aromatics and green chiles.

Squash casserole, Dallas cafeteria style | Homesick Texan


Highland Park’s version also used crackers to hold everything together, but the rest of the ingredient list was brief as it only called for onions, butter, and salt, and pepper. Or at least, that’s what I’ve heard. Because the owners of the cafeteria haven’t ruled out returning in another location, their methods are still a guarded secret.

Many years ago, however, The Dallas Morning News, published a recipe for what it believed was a close rendition to this prized casserole. Recently, when looking for ways to cook yellow squash and onions from my family’s farm, I decided to use the article as a guide.

The procedure is simple. First, you cook the onion and squash until soft. Then you stir in half-and-half and season the squash with salt and pepper. A handful of crushed saltines are blended into the mix, then you top everything with more crackers and butter, then bake it until it’s browned and bubbling.

The Morning News was absent any measurements, so I had to come up with my own. I will also confess that reading the recipe and even preparing it the first time didn’t inspire hope that it would turn out very good. I was wrong, and it was spectacular. And that’s the brilliance of this method, as the squash is allowed to shine.

Squash casserole, Dallas cafeteria style | Homesick Texan

It’s also not too heavy, which is a benefit when it’s hot outside. Sure, the oven is on briefly, but the end dish is comforting and worth the slight bit of time. Does it taste like the one so many grew up eating? I don’t know, but it’s elegant and easy, and a new welcome addition to my family’s table and repertoire of ways to prepare summer squash.

—————
Would you like more Homesick Texan? Well, I’ve started offering additional recipes for paid subscribers to help with the costs of running the site. While I’m not taking anything away, if you’d like to support Homesick Texan and have access to exclusive, never-seen-before subscriber-only posts, please consider becoming a member; annual subscriptions are as low as $25. Thank you for reading, your consideration, and your support!
—————

Squash casserole, Dallas cafeteria style | Homesick Texan
5 from 6 votes
Print

Squash casserole, Dallas cafeteria style

Course Side Dish
Cuisine Texan
Servings 8
Author Adapted from The Dallas Morning News by Lisa Fain

Ingredients

  • 6 tablespoons unsalted butter
  • 1 medium yellow onion, diced
  • 2 pounds yellow squash (about 4-5, depending on size), cut into half-moons
  • 1 teaspoon kosher salt
  • ½ teaspoon black pepper
  • ¼ cup half-and-half
  • 1 cup crushed saltines

Instructions

  1. Preheat the oven to 350°F.
  2. In a large cast-iron skillet, melt the butter on medium-low heat. Once melted, pour half the butter into a bowl, and set aside, leaving the rest in the skillet.
  3. Add the onions to the skillet, and while occasionally stirring, cook until softened and fragrant, about 5 minutes.
  4. Add the squash to the skillet, and while occasionally stirring, cook until the squash is softened, and any liquid released by the squash has evaporated, about 10 minutes.

  5. Season the squash with the salt and pepper, then stir in the half-and-half until well blended. Stir in half of the crushed crackers until well blended, then taste and adjust seasonings if needed.
  6. Evenly sprinkle the remaining crushed crackers on top, then drizzle the remaining melted butter over the crackers.
  7. Bake uncovered in the skillet (or you can trasnfer it to a greased baking dish, if you prefer) at 350°F for 25-30 minutes or until lightly browned. Serve warm.

  1. I never had the pleasure of eating at the Highland Park Cafeteria, but during my time in Houston, the squash casserole at Cleburne Cafeteria was my absolute favorite. I’ll be trying this as soon as I get my hands on some yellow squash; hoping it tastes just like I remember!

    • Lisa Fain

      DM–While I’m not sure if the Highland Park casserole was similar to Cleburne’s, I hope this lives up to your memory!

  2. Cindy Chambers

    This squash casserole sounds delicious! I will give it a try. I lived in Houston for over 60 years and I loved Luby’s. They also had a squash casserole/dish that had cheese and Fritos among its ingredients. I have searched high and low and tried to replicate it to no avail. Do you remember it? Do you have a recipe that might duplicate it?

    • Lisa Fain

      Hi Cindy–I don’t remember it but I will try to find it!

  3. Hi Lisa! Quick question: I have an alarming abundance of gigantic zucchini coming out of my garden right now. Do you think this would be adaptable to use it instead of yellow squash? Thanks!

    • Lisa Fain

      Lauren–While I haven’t tried it with zucchini, I’m pretty certain it will be just as good.

  4. Juliana Villacorta

    We have the same thing in Houston at Cleburne Cafeteria. One of my favorites!

  5. Melinda Loyd

    You read my mind! I picked up some yellow squash yesterday, with the intention of finding a recipe like this. Homesick Texan to the rescue🥰.
    The squash is cooking right now.
    Much love from Sherman!
    Melinda L

  6. It cooks in the oven in the cast iron skillet?

    • Lisa Fain

      I cooked mine in the skillet, though you can transfer it to a baking dish if you like.

  7. Lisa Dowdy

    My Granny, who lived in Gonzales, made something extremely similar. She had no recipe – boil the squash. Add salt, pepper, and butter. Top with buttered crackers and bake. My favorite way to eat squash.

    I’ll have to try this version. 🙂

  8. Hi Lisa- I am a texan living in Stockholm Sweden.. I would like to try this recipe and am wondering if you could substitute panko or something else for the saltines?

  9. Evelyn Fisher

    My guess is that theirs (like many old-style southern squash recipes) used boiled or “stewed” squash. It only takes a small amount of water to get it started, and the onion and butter can be put in the same pan. The water in the squash will do the rest. I love the idea of the half and half. Thanks for the reminder about this old-time favorite. I had an apartment about two blocks away from the Highland Park Cafeteria in the early 70s.

    • Lisa Fain

      Evelyn–Yes, many squash casserole recipes have you cook the squash in water. The Dallas Morning News’s article said to cook it in both butter and water before adding half and half, but when I tried it that way, it was much too soggy and I had to strain out the liquid. When I only used butter, it was just right.

  10. I have this in the oven right now! Taste tested it from the stove top, and I believe it is gonna be a new favorite recipe! I have a bottle of smoked kosher salt in my pantry (compliments of my husband who loves to smoke all things). So, of course I used that for the salt. My sampling I’ve had thus far makes me think this is a much better version of the squash casserole than what I grew up on. That one did have a good bit of water, and I think an egg in it. I can’t wait to load my plate up with this!!!

    • Lisa Fain

      Lisa–Hope you enjoyed the casserole. I love the idea to use smoked kosher salt!

  11. 5 stars
    Made a half recipe yesterday using an 8″ cast iron skillet so I could put it in the oven. I used Trader Joes golden round crackers since I had those on hand. I also added a small amount of finely diced red chili pepper as we like a little heat plus it added a nice color. Turned out wonderful. Will definitely make again. Pretty quick to put together too.

    • Lisa Fain

      Danita–Your changes sound awesome and I’ll have to try it that way. I’m so glad you enjoyed it!

  12. Peggi Davis

    I LOVED the squash casserole at Highland Park Cafeteria!!!! Thanks so much for the recipe.

Leave a Reply to Lisa Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating