Buttermilk peach ice cream DSC5287

Buttermilk peach ice cream on a summer morning

I was talking to my grandmother the other day, and she mentioned that she had just eaten a peach from her tree. “It was a perfect peach,” she said. The season is almost over in Texas, but it’s just begun here in New York so last Saturday I scooped up a few at the farmers’ market.

While our peaches aren’t as famous as Georgia’s, it’s difficult to find a more sweet, juicy and tangy peach than a Texas peach. And while, yes, we Texans like to brag about many things, peaches are near the top of my list.

My grandmother freezes bag upon bag of her peaches every year, and there are also plenty of peach pies and cobblers made with the harvest. But it’s reached that point in the summer when I no longer want to heat up my apartment by baking—I need my food to be quick and cool. So when it comes to peaches—what I’ve been craving is the soft floral flavor of peach ice cream.

Buttermilk peach ice cream  | Homesick Texan
Back home, we had Blue Bell’s Peaches & Homemade Vanilla available by the gallon during the summer months when you needed a taste. But here in New York City, I’ve seen peach sorbet but no peach ice cream. That’s not a problem, however, since homemade ice cream is always better than store bought.

I asked my grandmother for her peach ice cream recipe but she didn’t have one to give me. “Just throw the fruit in like you’d do with any fruit ice cream,” she said. She then shared with me her basic vanilla ice cream recipe, which sounded wonderful but a bit too complex.

I’m a simple person when it comes to my homemade ice cream. I don’t like to use anything but cream, sweetener and flavor. I know that lots of people prefer to make ice cream with eggs, but I’m too lazy and impatient to mess with making a custard. Instead, I just want to throw the ingredients into my ice-cream maker and whip it into something thick and delicious—the faster the better.

Buttermilk peach ice cream  | Homesick Texan
I mentioned that I had buttermilk on hand and I asked my grandmother what she thought about my including that with the cream. “That sounds fabulous!” she said. “And I would love some of that though I reckon it doesn’t ship very well.” So, I promised to make her some next time I visited.

I think that super ripe peaches make for the best ice cream. And my favorite way to ripen them is to leave them sitting in a bowl in the window for a couple of days. In the heat, the fruit becomes soft more quickly, plus whenever a breeze comes in through the screen, the air smells of peaches.

When they’re ripe and I’m ready to make ice cream, I peel and quarter them and then toss the peaches with lemon juice, cinnamon and sugar. I place them in the refrigerator to steep overnight, which vastly improves the intensity of the flavor.

Buttermilk peach ice cream  | Homesick Texan
In the morning, I mix buttermilk with the cream, add some vanilla and then stir in the peaches. I pour the mix into my ice cream maker and half an hour later, I’m eating fresh peach ice cream for breakfast.

I can’t think of a sweeter, cooler way to start a sultry summer day. Can you?

Would you like more Homesick Texan? Well, I’ve started offering additional recipes for paid subscribers to help with the costs of running the site. While I’m not taking anything away, if you’d like to support Homesick Texan and have access to exclusive, never-seen-before subscriber-only posts, please consider becoming a member; annual subscriptions are as low as $25. Thank you for reading, your consideration, and your support!

4.57 from 16 votes

Buttermilk peach ice cream

Servings 1 quart
Author Lisa Fain


  • 2 cups sliced peaches, fresh, or frozen and thawed
  • 3/4 cups sugar
  • 2 tablespoons lemon juice
  • 1/2 teaspoon ground cinnamon
  • 2 cups cream
  • 1 cup buttermilk
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla


  • Toss peeled and sliced peaches with sugar, lemon juice, and cinnamon. Cover, refrigerate and let macerate at least for a couple of hours, preferably overnight or all day.
  • Puree 1 1/2 cups of the peaches (save the rest for mixing in after you make your ice cream), and then mix puree with cream, buttermilk and vanilla.
  • Freeze according to your ice-cream maker’s instructions.
  • Note: To peel the peaches, I place them into a pot of boiling water for 30 seconds, and then transfer them to a bowl filled with ice water to halt the cooking. The skin should rub right off after blanching. If you use canned, you also might want to use less sugar if they were canned in syrup.


If you're using whole peaches, the amount can vary depending on size, anywhere from 4-6. If you're concerned about wasting produce, I'd start with the smaller number and go from there. 

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating


  1. Timothy West says:

    Hope this turns out. 1 pound of peaches equals 2+ cups. The recipe calls for 2 pound or 2 cups. Which is it? 5 of my peaches equalled 2 pounds.

      1. Shoot! I just peeled 6 peaches and it’s way more than 2 cups. I’ve had it in the fridge with the sugar, lemon and cinnamon for a couple hours but now I think it won’t be nearly enough sugar, etc for the amount of peaches. Please fix this in the recipe if you get a moment. I hate wasting expensive produce as I now have way too much already macerating. Still hopeful it will be tasty! I’ll probably toss the extra into a pastry shell and bake it off, so all is not lost, but still.

        1. Lisa Fain says:

          Kate–I will update the recipe to reflect your experience, and I’m sorry that it didn’t work out for you. Peaches can very in size and I’m guessing that yours were larger than the ones initially used when writing the recipe. I would taste your mixture for sweetness and see if you need to make any adjustments, and you will most likely be fine. Thank you for the feedback.